The Language of Trust: Overcoming Employee Hesitation in Retirement Plans
Despite widespread access to employer-sponsored retirement plans, many employees remain hesitant to fully engage. While automation features and plan design have helped raise participation rates, long-term savings behavior often hinges on a critical, and frequently underestimated, ingredient: trust.
Behavioral finance insights, particularly those from people like Shlomo Benartzi, reveal that employees aren’t simply rational decision-makers. Their reluctance to save consistently in 401(k), 403(b), or 457(b) plans is often rooted in emotional friction: fear, confusion, or feeling overwhelmed.[1] For ERISA advisors striving to do more than meet fiduciary minimums, the path forward begins by building trust.
Trust Takes Time and Touchpoints
Scott Hayes of ISC Group shared on a recent 90 North podcast: “Trust is something that’s earned over a long period of time. You don’t gain credibility on day one.”[2] At Tropical Texas Behavioral Health, CEO Terry Crocker highlighted the importance of personal connection, saying, “You’re not passed through a phone tree — you talk to someone who knows your name.”[2]
Employees notice consistency. Regular, face-to-face support from advisors fosters familiarity, which over time becomes trust.
Understanding the Human Side of Retirement Decisions
Benartzi’s research outlines how behavioral hurdles like present bias, inertia, and complexity prevent employees from acting—even when logic favors it.[1] According to Fidelity Investments, 57% of employees feel overwhelmed by financial decisions, and 60% lack confidence in their choices.[3] Capital Group reports that 62% of workers don’t feel their provider communicates in ways they fully understand.[4]
Kelly Majdan, speaking to employee financial literacy and wellness, put it plainly: “We’re not just dealing with plans. We’re dealing with people, and people are complicated.”[2] Kelly goes on to note that relatable success stories provide hope and will, many times nudge other employees to act. [2]
What Advisors and Benefits Professionals Can Do to Build and Earn Trust
- Speak in plain language: Replace jargon with messages that resonate emotionally and practically.
- Establish consistency: Ongoing touchpoints—onsite, virtual, or hybrid—signal reliability.
- Segment and personalize: Tailor education by life stage and priorities. J.P. Morgan research shows personalization can increase engagement by up to 40%.[5]
- Start with a baseline survey: Gauge employees’ confidence, awareness, and financial stress levels.
- Use stories, not stats: Share relatable success stories. As Kelly Majdan noted, stories create hope and nudge employees into the action stage.
The Long Game: Behavior Change Isn’t Instant
Behavioral change follows the trans-theoretical model of change: pre-contemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, and maintenance. Forming sustainable savings habits can take 6 to 12 months or more.[2]
Initial engagement may be just 5–10%, and that’s okay. Early adopters represent momentum, not a ceiling.
✅ Action Steps for ERISA Advisors and Plan Fiduciaries
- Consider launching an annual trust and readiness survey.
- Build a calendar with quarterly, customized education touchpoints.
- Refine all participant materials using language that informs and empowers.
- Share internal success stories—highlight real employees with real progress.
- Track trust indicators alongside participation metrics.
🧭 Building Trust Leads to Lasting Change: The Reward is Transformed Outcomes
Trust is the language employees speak before they act. When they believe the plan is for them and that the people guiding them are invested in their success, everything changes.
For ERISA advisors and plan committees who commit to this work, the reward isn’t just increased participation—it’s transformed outcomes.
Ready to build trust and drive better retirement plan outcomes? Contact 90 North Consulting today to explore how we can help you make a lasting impact.





