Private Equity in 401(k) Plans: What You Need to Know

Why Private Equity Is Entering the 401(k) Conversation

As demand grows for enhanced participant outcomes and broader diversification options, the topic of private equity and other private market investments in defined contribution plans is drawing renewed attention. Plan sponsors and advisors are asking whether these vehicles—once the domain of institutional defined benefit (DB) plans—can play a role in participant-directed defined contribution (DC) plans like 401(k)s. While recent developments have opened the door slightly, fiduciaries still face considerable uncertainty and responsibility.

Here’s what you need to know to include where we’ve been, where we are, and what potentially lies ahead.


A Look Back: How We Got Here

In June 2020, the Department of Labor issued an information letter clarifying that ERISA fiduciaries could, under certain conditions, include private equity exposure in diversified, professionally managed asset allocations such as target-date or balanced funds. The DOL emphasized that private equity should not be offered as a standalone investment option. The letter signaled a cautious openness to private equity, provided the fiduciary undertook a thorough and well-documented process, particularly around evaluating manager expertise, valuation practices, and participant needs.

Later, in December 2021, the DOL issued a supplemental statement urging fiduciaries to exercise heightened caution—especially for small and mid-sized plans—underscoring that the 2020 letter should not be interpreted as a green light for broad adoption.


Defined Benefit vs. Defined Contribution: Key Differences

One theory on justifying private equity in defined contribution plans is that private equity has long been used by DB plans to meet long-term return targets and manage liabilities. These plans are typically overseen by institutional investment teams with significant expertise, and they operate under a pooled-fund model where liquidity is less of a concern.

However, the risk for investment performance in DB plans rests with the employer and not the employee.  If a decision by plan fiduciaries to invest in private markets results in a loss, then the plan sponsor would be the one responsible for making up for the loss to meet obligations and promised benefits to participants.  Stated a different way, the participants do not bear the risk.

Defined contribution plans, by contrast, shift risk, investment decisions, and liquidity needs to individual participants. This creates additional challenges when considering private equity, including the need for daily valuation, liquidity constraints, and participant education. These differences mean fiduciaries should generally apply a distinct and often more conservative lens when evaluating private equity in a 401(k) context.


How Private Equity Compares to Traditional Investment Vehicles

Private market investments may offer long-term return potential, diversification, and access to sectors not typically represented in public markets. But these benefits come with material trade-offs.

Compared to traditional 1940 Act mutual funds, collective investment trusts (CITs), and separately managed accounts, private equity structures typically involve higher fees, greater complexity, longer lock-up periods, and opaque valuation methodologies. Fiduciaries must weigh these characteristics against participant demographics, investment goals, and plan size when evaluating their appropriateness.


What We Know Now

While the 2020 DOL letter remains in effect, more recent regulatory and legislative developments suggest a shift toward greater scrutiny. Some large providers, including Empower, have begun offering CITs that incorporate private equity components within diversified strategies. This move has attracted attention from lawmakers, including Senator Elizabeth Warren, who questioned whether these offerings adequately protect participants and whether providers are being sufficiently transparent[i].

To date, these newer efforts appear to build upon, rather than replace, the framework established in 2020. The core concept remains: private equity may be permissible within a multi-asset, professionally managed structure if fiduciaries can demonstrate a prudent evaluation and monitoring process. However, emerging proposals may add new standards for disclosures, valuation consistency, and participant protections.


What We Don’t Know Yet

Several key questions remain unanswered. Final DOL and SEC guidance around transparency, liquidity, and reporting standards is expected but not yet released. Most significantly, we also lack long-term empirical data on how private equity exposure in DC plans affects participant outcomes.  In other words, beyond the compliance, disclosure, risk and return issues, will this improve participant outcomes, and is it generally in the best interests of plan participants and beneficiaries?

Another unknown is the litigation landscape. While early legal challenges, such as the Intel case, have affirmed some uses of alternatives in multi-asset funds, it remains unclear how courts will treat broader inclusion of private market exposure in plans of varying size and complexity.


Comparing Private Equity and Crypto Guidance

The contrast between the DOL’s treatment of private equity and crypto assets is telling. In 2022, the DOL issued a compliance assistance bulletin that strongly discouraged the inclusion of cryptocurrency in ERISA plans, citing concerns about valuation, custody, and volatility. In contrast, the tone around private equity has been more measured—permissive in certain contexts and with rigorous oversight. This indicates the DOL is not categorically opposed to alternatives but is deeply concerned with fiduciary capacity and participant protection.

The DOL did rescind its guidance on crypto assets in ERISA plans, citing as a reason that ERISA has no such term or statute that would describe “[t]he standard of ‘extreme care,’” used in the original guidance.


What to Expect Next

As of mid-2025, regulators appear poised to move toward more formal guidance by late 2025 or early 2026. These updates may codify expectations around disclosures, fee structures, liquidity arrangements, and fiduciary process. Meanwhile, more recordkeepers and asset managers are likely to test the waters through pilot programs within large plans. We also expect continued congressional interest and potential legislative proposals.

Litigation will likely play a formative role in setting boundaries. As more plans consider private equity exposure, particularly with the potential use in custom target-date funds or white-label balanced options, the courts may further shape what constitutes a prudent process under ERISA.


What Sponsors and Advisors Should Do Now

For most plan sponsors, particularly those overseeing small to mid-sized plans, the best course of action may be to wait and observe. This “watch and wait” approach allows fiduciaries to monitor how larger plans are navigating these offerings and how regulators respond.

That said, forward-thinking sponsors and advisors can begin to prepare. Evaluate your committee’s investment expertise, governance framework, and risk tolerance. Document all discussions related to private equity or private markets. If considering future inclusion, identify potential managers with experience in delivering private equity exposure within daily-valued vehicles. Begin internal education around liquidity, valuation, and fee considerations.

A significant question to ask in your decision-making should be, “Is there evidence and data to suggest that this will improve participant outcomes?”

In short, proceed cautiously—but remain informed. The private markets discussion is no longer theoretical. It is happening, and fiduciaries have a responsibility to understand the implications.

We hope this newsletter inspires you to think beyond the basics of fiduciary responsibility and embrace a more holistic, impactful approach to leadership, stewardship, and governance. Please feel free to share this with your network, and don’t hesitate to reach out for further discussion or resources.


Read more articles on our LinkedIn Newsletter: Be More Than a Fiduciary for more news and updates.

Reach out to 90 North Consulting for guidance on evolving fiduciary best practices and alternative investments in retirement plans.

Eric Dyson Executive Director 90 North Consulting

Executive Director, 90 North Consulting

edyson@90northllc.com

940-248-4800

The information and content of this newsletter is general in nature and is provided solely for educational and informational purposes. It is believed to be accurate and reliable as of the posting date but may be subject to change

It is not intended to provide a specific recommendation for any type of product or service discussed or to provide any warranties, investment advice, financial advice, tax, plan design or legal advice (unless otherwise specifically indicated). Please consult your own independent advisor or legal counsel as to any investment, tax, or legal statements made.

The specific facts and circumstances of all qualified plans can vary and the information contained in this newsletter may or may not apply to your individual circumstances or to your plan or client plan-specific circumstances.

Check out our latest podcast episodes

1x

Stay Informed: Explore Our Latest Newsletter Articles

Introducing Polaris

Introducing POLARIS

Beyond the Investment Policy Statement: From Fiduciary Policy to Fiduciary Practice Why Meaningful Benchmark Selection Deserves a More Deliberate Fiduciary Process From Confusion to Compliance

Read More >>