Managed Accounts as QDIAs: Balancing Prudence, Process and Participant Needs

Episode 4 in the Be More Than a Fiduciary Managed Accounts Series

Managed accounts are evolving as a core component of defined contribution plan design, promising personalized advice and allocations tailored to individual participants. As more plan sponsors explore their potential as a Qualified Default Investment Alternative (QDIA), it’s important to step back and ask a fundamental question: Does a managed account solution meet the prudent process standard ERISA demands, for a specific plan and a specific employer demographic?

In this final edition of our four-part series on managed accounts, we focus squarely on the fiduciary considerations surrounding the use of managed accounts as the QDIA. This means diving into regulations, understanding litigation trends, and evaluating data from plans already offering these solutions.


What the QDIA Regulations Permit

Under Department of Labor regulations, fiduciaries may designate three types of investments as QDIAs: target-date funds, balanced funds, and managed accounts. Each is intended to serve participants who do not make affirmative investment elections. Managed accounts meet the regulatory definition of a QDIA when they allocate assets based on participant characteristics such as age, salary, and projected retirement date.

These rules provide flexibility and a potential safe harbor if the guidance is fully and properly followed.  But as specifically stated, they do not relieve fiduciaries of their general fiduciary responsibilities under ERISA Section 404(a). Those duties include evaluating the reasonableness of fees and confirming that the managed account solution is appropriate given the demographics and needs of the plan’s participant base.


Fiduciary Duties Remain Central

Selecting a managed account provider to serve as the plan’s QDIA is not a passive act. Fiduciaries are expected to, among other requirements:

  • Establish that the managed account structure fits the needs of their participants
  • Evaluate the methodology used to personalize portfolios
  • Review the fee structure in relation to the services provided
  • Evaluate alternative potential managed accounts
  • Monitor performance and utilization over time

Simply meeting the minimum regulatory criteria does not fulfill a fiduciary’s ongoing duty of prudence. A well-documented process that demonstrates thoughtful selection and monitoring is essential.


Understanding Cost Differences Across QDIA Types

While all QDIAs must meet fiduciary standards under ERISA, it’s important to acknowledge the cost implications across different default structures. Managed accounts typically carry higher participant-level fees than target-date funds or balanced funds, due in part to the customization and advisory overlay involved. In contrast, TDFs offer a streamlined, lower-cost allocation model that scales efficiently across participants.

It is worth noting that when the Department of Labor first issued QDIA regulations in 2007, there appears to have been little explicit recognition that different QDIA types might vary significantly in cost. The guidance does not offer a comparative framework or fee thresholds by product type. Instead, it emphasizes that fiduciaries must apply the general standards of prudence and loyalty, including ensuring that fees are reasonable relative to the services provided.

As managed accounts become more common and litigation emerges around cost justification, fiduciaries should not assume that QDIA designation alone insulates higher-cost products from scrutiny. Documenting why a higher-cost managed account delivers meaningful value to participants is essential.


No Obligation to Compare QDIA Types, But Process Still Matters

It’s worth noting that the QDIA regulations do not require plan fiduciaries to compare different types of QDIAs. There is no mandate to show that a managed account is superior to a target-date fund or vice versa.

However, this is where fiduciaries should consider the spirit of the law. If a target-date fund offers better net-of-fee outcomes for a given participant base, choosing a more expensive managed account without a clear justification may still invite scrutiny. It’s not about finding the perfect solution, but about applying a prudent, well-reasoned process that serves participants’ best interests.


Recent Litigation Reinforces These Standards

Courts are increasingly evaluating whether fiduciaries followed a sound process when selecting or retaining managed accounts. Three recent cases offer helpful insights:

In Kimberly-Clark, fiduciaries settled a $2.25 million lawsuit that alleged excessive recordkeeping and administrative fees, highlighting the importance of fee oversight across all plan services, including managed accounts.

In Bechtel, a dismissed lawsuit challenged the use of managed accounts as a QDIA due to their higher fees compared to target-date funds. The court ruled in favor of the plan fiduciaries, emphasizing that the plaintiff failed to present a meaningful benchmark or evidence of imprudence.

In Dover Corporation, a class action lawsuit alleged that fiduciaries failed to monitor and control the fees associated with managed account services provided by Financial Engines. The plaintiffs claimed the services did not justify the cost and that fiduciaries failed to negotiate lower fees based on plan size. While the case is ongoing, it reflects heightened legal attention to managed account fee structures.


What Industry Data Shows

Managed account adoption has grown, but it remains a minority strategy when used as the QDIA. According to NEPC’s 2024 Defined Contribution Survey, 46 percent of plans offer managed accounts, but only 9 percent use them as the default investment. Meanwhile, over 86 percent of plans continue to use target-date funds as the QDIA, and that number rises to 92 percent for larger plans with over 5,000 participants.

Most plans with a managed account QDIA operate on an opt-out basis, meaning participants are automatically defaulted unless they affirmatively choose another investment. This makes the fiduciary’s selection process even more critical, as the majority of participants will typically end up in the default option.


Best Practices in Selection and Monitoring

Fiduciaries considering or already using managed accounts as a QDIA should ask:

  • Does the provider personalize accounts using relevant participant data such as age, salary, contribution rate, and outside assets?
  • What percentage of defaulted participants take no additional action to personalize their managed account, and may be paying for a service that is essentially not being used?
  • To what degree are participants personalizing?  Do participants utilize all personalization features, or is engagement limited compared to the personalization available?
  • Are the fees reasonable for the services provided, and how do they compare to benchmarks?
  • Is the provider delivering actual advice or simply running a model portfolio with limited engagement?
  • Are participants seeing improved outcomes or increased savings behavior as a result?

Ongoing monitoring should include not just investment performance but also adoption rates, utilization trends, and participant outcomes. All decisions should be documented in meeting minutes or investment committee records.


What About Dynamic QDIAs?

Some plan sponsors are exploring dynamic QDIA structures, which default younger participants into target-date funds and then transition them into managed accounts as they approach retirement. While this structure is relatively new, the fiduciary responsibilities remain the same. Each component must be prudently selected and monitored, and the transition methodology should be clearly defined and participant-centered.


What Plan Fiduciaries Should Do Now

  1. Review your current QDIA and assess whether it continues to meet the needs of your participant base. Document this process in committee meeting minutes!!
  2. If you are considering a managed account provider or already using one, evaluate the value delivered relative to fees and complexity.
  3. Confirm that your committee has a documented process in place to periodically review your QDIA selection and determine whether changes are needed.
  4. Ensure that your documented process is more than a collection of data for the managed account.  Establish meaningful monitoring criteria and evaluate the information available.
  5. Stay informed on litigation and regulatory trends to ensure your practices remain aligned with ERISA fiduciary expectations.

Managed accounts may offer personalized advantages, but they are not a stand-alone fiduciary shield. The key question isn’t whether a managed account is allowed; it’s whether it is prudent. As plan sponsors and advisors, as plan fiduciaries, the job is not to chase innovation, but to use it wisely. When managed accounts are chosen and monitored with rigor and clarity, they can support both fiduciary goals and better retirement outcomes.

Now is the time to take a closer look.

We hope this newsletter inspires you to think beyond the basics of fiduciary responsibility and embrace a more holistic, impactful approach to leadership, stewardship, and governance. Please feel free to share this with your network, and don’t hesitate to reach out for further discussion or resources.


Note: This newsletter focuses on the QDIA types explicitly addressed in the Department of Labor’s 2007 regulation: target-date funds, balanced funds, and managed accounts. More specifically, it is focused on managed accounts as part of the newsletter series on the topic.  For completeness, please note that recent legislative and regulatory developments, including the SECURE Act and SECURE 2.0, have opened the door for plan sponsors to explore the inclusion of retirement income solutions within QDIA frameworks or as standalone default options at retirement. While not formally recognized as a fourth QDIA type by regulation, these developments are relevant for fiduciaries evaluating lifetime income strategies and may evolve into new default structures subject to additional guidance.

Eric Dyson Executive Director 90 North Consulting

Executive Director, 90 North Consulting

edyson@90northllc.com

940-248-4800

The information and content of this newsletter is general in nature and is provided solely for educational and informational purposes. It is believed to be accurate and reliable as of the posting date but may be subject to change

It is not intended to provide a specific recommendation for any type of product or service discussed or to provide any warranties, investment advice, financial advice, tax, plan design or legal advice (unless otherwise specifically indicated). Please consult your own independent advisor or legal counsel as to any investment, tax, or legal statements made.

The specific facts and circumstances of all qualified plans can vary and the information contained in this newsletter may or may not apply to your individual circumstances or to your plan or client plan-specific circumstances.

Check out our latest podcast episodes

1x

Stay Informed: Explore Our Latest Newsletter Articles

Introducing Polaris

Introducing POLARIS

Beyond the Investment Policy Statement: From Fiduciary Policy to Fiduciary Practice Why Meaningful Benchmark Selection Deserves a More Deliberate Fiduciary Process From Confusion to Compliance

Read More >>