Elevating ERISA Fiduciary Standards by Starting with ‘Why?’

Introduction

ERISA fiduciary duties stem from a cornerstone of responsible retirement plan governance, safeguarding participants’ interests. However, beyond mere compliance, embracing a purpose-driven framework can transform these duties into acts of true leadership, stewardship, and governance. Simon Sinek’s concept of “Start with Why” encourages leaders to anchor their actions in a clear purpose, fostering deeper trust and engagement. This week’s Be More Than a Fiduciary newsletter explores how plan fiduciaries can define their “Why” for each ERISA duty—contrasting minimal compliance with exemplary stewardship—and offers actionable insights for committees, advisors, and service providers.

The Golden Circle Framework: Starting with ‘Why’ in ERISA Fiduciary Duties

Simon Sinek’s Golden Circle model emphasizes that inspiring leaders and organizations operate from the inside out, beginning with ‘Why‘—their core purpose or belief—followed by ‘How‘ they achieve it, and ‘What‘ they produce. This approach suggests that when fiduciaries ground their responsibilities in a compelling ‘Why,’ they not only fulfill regulatory obligations but also inspire confidence and commitment among plan participants.

Defining ‘Why’ for ERISA Fiduciary Duties

a. Duty of Loyalty (Acting solely in participants’ best interests)

  • Minimal Compliance Why: “To fulfill legal obligations and avoid potential penalties.”
  • Stewardship Why: “To honor the trust participants place in us, ensuring every decision enhances their financial well-being.”

Simon Sinek insight: “There are many ways to motivate people to do things, but loyalty comes from the ability to inspire people.”

b. Duty of Prudence (Making informed, skillful, and diligent decisions)

  • Minimal Compliance Why: “To adhere to industry standards and mitigate risks.”
  • Stewardship Why: “To empower participants with confidence in their retirement journey through meticulous and thoughtful management.”

Simon Sinek insight: “Trust is maintained when values and beliefs are actively managed.”

c. Duty to Diversify Investments (Reducing unnecessary risk to participants’ assets)

  • Minimal Compliance Why: “To comply with diversification requirements and minimize potential liabilities.”
  • Stewardship Why: “To provide a resilient investment portfolio that supports participants’ diverse retirement goals.”

Simon Sinek insight: “Happy employees ensure happy customers. And happy customers ensure happy shareholders—in that order.”

d. Duty to Follow Plan Documents (Adhering to governing plan rules and ERISA requirements)

  • Minimal Compliance Why: “To ensure regulatory adherence and maintain plan qualification.”
  • Stewardship Why: “To uphold the integrity and transparency of the plan, fostering trust and clarity among participants.”

Simon Sinek insight: “For values or guiding principles to be truly effective they have to be verbs. It’s not ‘integrity,’ it’s ‘always do the right thing.'”

Implementing a Purpose-Driven Fiduciary Approach

  • Reflect and Define: Fiduciary committees should engage in discussions to articulate their collective ‘Why’ for each duty, moving beyond compliance to genuine participant advocacy.
  • Align Policies: Ensure that investment policy statements, governance structures, and communication strategies reflect this deeper purpose.
  • Educate and Inspire: Regular training sessions can reinforce the organization’s ‘Why,’ inspiring all stakeholders to embody these principles in their roles.

The Impact of Defining a Strong ‘Why’

Anchoring fiduciary duties in a well-defined purpose leads to:

  • Enhanced Decision-Making: Purpose-driven fiduciaries are more likely to make consistent, participant-focused decisions.
  • Increased Trust: Participants who perceive genuine care and alignment with their interests are more likely to trust and engage with the plan.
  • Cultural Cohesion: A shared ‘Why’ fosters a unified culture among fiduciaries, advisors, and service providers, leading to collaborative success.

Summary and Action Items

For Committee Members:

  • Consider scheduling a plan strategy meeting with your service providers once a year.  Explore and document the committee’s overarching purpose beyond regulatory compliance.
  • Set goals and visions for your benefit strategy that go beyond participation rate and deferral rate.  Defining your “Why,” involves creating an enterprise level benefit strategy as well as a strategy for your ERISA health and retirement plans.  Note this concept applies to governmental entities and other organizations that may be exempt from ERISA.
  • Regularly assess decisions against this purpose to ensure alignment.

For ERISA Plan Advisors:

  • Facilitate discussions with clients to uncover and articulate their ‘Why,’ integrating it into plan design and participant interactions.
  • Develop Key Performance Indicator (“KPI”) metrics to evaluate how well the plan’s operations reflect this purpose.

For Service Providers:

  • Align services and products to support the client’s defined ‘Why,’ demonstrating commitment to their mission.
  • Provide feedback on how processes can better embody the plan’s purpose, enhancing overall effectiveness.

Conclusion

While compliance with ERISA fiduciary duties is a legal obligation, embracing a purpose-driven approach elevates fiduciaries from rule-followers to true stewards of participant well-being. By starting with ‘Why,’ fiduciaries can inspire trust, drive meaningful engagement, and ultimately enhance the retirement outcomes for those they serve.

We hope this newsletter inspires you to think beyond the basics of fiduciary responsibility and embrace a more holistic, impactful approach to leadership, stewardship, and governance. Please feel free to share this with your network, and don’t hesitate to reach out for further discussion or resources.

Revisit “Elevating ERISA Fiduciary Standards by Starting with Why?” to gain deeper insights and actionable strategies for enhancing fiduciary stewardship.
Eric Dyson Executive Director 90 North Consulting

Executive Director, 90 North Consulting

edyson@90northllc.com

940-248-4800

The information and content of this newsletter is general in nature and is provided solely for educational and informational purposes. It is believed to be accurate and reliable as of the posting date but may be subject to change

It is not intended to provide a specific recommendation for any type of product or service discussed or to provide any warranties, investment advice, financial advice, tax, plan design or legal advice (unless otherwise specifically indicated). Please consult your own independent advisor or legal counsel as to any investment, tax, or legal statements made.

The specific facts and circumstances of all qualified plans can vary and the information contained in this newsletter may or may not apply to your individual circumstances or to your plan or client plan-specific circumstances.

Check out our latest podcast episodes

1x

Stay Informed: Explore Our Latest Newsletter Articles

Introducing Polaris

Introducing POLARIS

Beyond the Investment Policy Statement: From Fiduciary Policy to Fiduciary Practice Why Meaningful Benchmark Selection Deserves a More Deliberate Fiduciary Process From Confusion to Compliance

Read More >>