Signature Principle Three: Examples Should Inform Judgment, Not
Define It
This is the third installment in our series exploring the Eight Signature Principles of Thoughtful Fiduciary Leadership. These principles emerged from our review of the Department of Labor’s proposed guidance governing the selection of designated investment alternatives and the hundreds of public comments submitted in response.
One observation stood out almost immediately. The Department used numerous examples throughout the proposal to illustrate how fiduciaries might apply the principles contained in the proposed regulation. Yet many commenters discussed those examples almost as though they represented regulatory requirements or preferred practices rather than illustrations of a prudent fiduciary process.
That distinction matters.
Examples are valuable teaching tools. They help committees understand how fiduciary principles might apply under a particular set of facts and circumstances. But examples are not, by themselves, the rule.
That simple observation leads to our third Signature Principle of Thoughtful Fiduciary Leadership:
Examples should inform fiduciary judgment, never define it.
We Have Seen This Before
For some readers, the Pension Protection Act of 2006 is retirement plan history.
For others of us, thanks to a little gray hair and many years working with retirement plans, it is something we remember firsthand. You can usually identify us because our mailbox, email inbox, and social media feed have suddenly become convinced we need information about Medicare supplements.
When automatic enrollment became widely adopted following the Pension Protection Act, one number quickly became familiar throughout the retirement industry: 3%.
The Department of Labor used a 3% automatic enrollment contribution rate in its examples. Unfortunately, many treated that example as though it reflected the Department’s preferred contribution rate.
It didn’t.
In fact, most retirement professionals, advisers, consultants, recordkeepers, and plan fiduciaries understood that a 3% savings rate was generally not enough to help participants accumulate adequate retirement savings. Yet 3% became remarkably common, not because the industry believed it was the right long-term savings rate, but because many assumed that if the Department used it as an example, that must be what prudent fiduciaries were expected to do.
Over time, experience proved otherwise. Plans increasingly adopted higher default contribution rates, automatic escalation, and designs intended to produce better retirement outcomes.
The Department provided an example. The industry turned it into a standard.
That is exactly the mistake thoughtful fiduciaries should avoid repeating.
A Current Example
The Department’s current proposal gives us an opportunity to apply that lesson today.
One example describes a fiduciary committee’s evaluation of a designated investment alternative that includes private equity alongside publicly traded investments. In the example, the committee prudently engages an independent ERISA Section 3(21)(A)(ii) investment advice fiduciary to help develop and explain an appropriate custom benchmark for evaluating that investment. The Department concludes that the fiduciary satisfies its prudence obligations because it understood the benchmark, evaluated the investment appropriately, and exercised informed fiduciary judgment.

Now notice what the Department did not say.
- It did not say every retirement plan should include private assets.
- It did not say every retirement plan should hire a Section 3(21) investment advice fiduciary.
- It did not say every committee should construct custom benchmarks.
The Department simply illustrated one prudent fiduciary process under one particular set of facts and circumstances.
That distinction is critically important.
If this example appears in the final regulation, thoughtful fiduciaries should not conclude that the Department expects every plan to add private assets or retain a 3(21) adviser. Instead, committees should understand the underlying principle the Department is illustrating and then determine whether those facts, those investments, and that process are appropriate for their own plan and participants.
Once again, the example informs judgment.
It does not replace judgment.
The Better Fiduciary Question
The right question is not:
“What did the Department’s example do?”
The better question is:
“What fiduciary principle is the Department illustrating, and how does that principle apply to our committee, our participants, and our circumstances?”

That is precisely what ERISA expects.
The proposed guidance repeatedly emphasizes that fiduciaries should determine whether they possess the skills, knowledge, experience, and capacity necessary to evaluate increasingly complex investments or whether they should obtain qualified professional assistance. That is an exercise of fiduciary judgment, not a regulatory mandate.
The same principle extends well beyond investment selection. Committees routinely encounter model investment policy statements, sample committee charters, governance checklists, benchmarking reports, RFP templates, and industry best practices. Each may provide valuable ideas. None should substitute for independent fiduciary analysis.
What Committees Can Do
As your committee reviews new guidance, separate actual regulatory requirements from illustrative examples.

When an example appears in guidance, ask what fiduciary principle it is intended to teach rather than whether it should be copied.
Periodically evaluate whether your committee possesses the knowledge and experience necessary to make increasingly complex investment decisions.
Seek qualified fiduciary expertise whenever your committee concludes that doing so will improve its decision-making process.
Finally, document your committee’s reasoning. A prudent fiduciary process explains why a committee reached its decision, not simply that it followed someone else’s example.
A Practical Observation
At 90 North Consulting, we strongly believe in the value that an experienced independent investment consultant can bring to many retirement plan committees, particularly as investment structures become more sophisticated and fiduciary expectations continue to evolve. That does not mean every plan requires an ERISA Section 3(21) investment advice fiduciary or a Section 3(38) investment manager.
It does mean every committee should thoughtfully evaluate whether additional expertise would strengthen its fiduciary process.
That belief is one reason we conduct independent searches for both ERISA Section 3(21) investment advisers and Section 3(38) investment managers on behalf of plan sponsors. The objective is not simply to find an adviser. It is to help committees determine whether additional fiduciary expertise is appropriate and, if so, identify the professional whose experience, philosophy, and services best fit the committee’s needs.
One Final Observation
Some of us are old enough to remember when 3% automatic enrollment was new.
We have also been around long enough to see what happens when a useful illustration quietly becomes an industry standard.
As the Department of Labor moves toward issuing final guidance, thoughtful fiduciaries should study the examples carefully, understand the principles they are intended to illustrate, and then continue doing what ERISA has always required: exercising thoughtful, independent fiduciary judgment.
Examples can illuminate fiduciary judgment. They should never replace it.
We hope this newsletter inspires you to think beyond the basics of fiduciary responsibility and embrace a more holistic, impactful approach to leadership, stewardship, and governance. Please feel free to share this with your network, and don’t hesitate to reach out for further discussion or resources.
Explore the full discussion of Signature Principle Two in our LinkedIn article.





