Signature Principle Eight: Fiduciary Excellence Is a Framework, Not a Formula
A Question Worth Asking
Most fiduciary committees have processes. They have an Investment Policy Statement, meeting calendars, investment reports, monitoring criteria, committee charters, minutes, policies, checklists, advisors, counsel, and service providers. All of those things can contribute to thoughtful fiduciary governance.
But consider a different question: What is your fiduciary framework?
Could the members of your committee describe it? Could your advisor? Could your service providers explain how their own framework complements yours?
Having fiduciary processes is not necessarily the same thing as having a fiduciary framework. A committee can execute a process extremely well, but if the framework supporting that process is poorly constructed, eventually the frame may begin to crumble around even excellent execution. Conversely, an excellent framework accomplishes little if fiduciaries fail to consistently execute the processes that support it.
Fiduciaries need both.
This distinction can also be considered through the concepts of substantive prudence and procedural prudence. Substantive prudence considers whether the framework and process themselves are sound. Procedural prudence considers whether fiduciaries actually execute a prudent decision making process. A good framework without disciplined execution is insufficient, and disciplined execution within a bad framework is equally insufficient. Fiduciary excellence requires both.
That brings us to the eighth Signature Principle.
What we learned from the public comment record: Beneath disagreement, there is a common framework.
Signature Principle Eight: Fiduciary excellence is a framework, not a formula.

We Went Looking and Expected Disagreement
When we began reviewing the public comments submitted in response to the Department of Labor’s proposed guidance, we expected to find competing answers, and we did. Commenters disagreed about investments, complexity, expertise, regulatory specificity, examples, safe harbors, flexibility, and how fiduciaries should evaluate different solutions.
Beneath those disagreements, however, something interesting emerged. Again and again, we encountered recurring concepts, including prudence, loyalty, thoughtful process, independent judgment, participant outcomes, disciplined documentation, appropriate flexibility, and careful evaluation of innovation.
The important finding was not that thoughtful fiduciaries will always reach the same conclusion. They will not. ERISA does not demand identical answers from every fiduciary confronting every set of circumstances. What matters is the framework within which judgment is exercised.
A formula seeks to produce the same answer. A framework provides a disciplined way to reach a thoughtful answer.
The Frame of a Submarine
During my Navy career, I served aboard submarines. Few environments demonstrate the importance of a framework quite like a submarine.
Consider the people who make up a submarine crew:
- Cooks and yeomen
- Sonar technicians and electronic warfare specialists
- Nuclear trained sailors
- Junior and senior officers
- The commanding officer
- Many other sailors with highly specialized responsibilities

Their jobs, training, expertise, experiences, and perspectives are different. They certainly do not always look at a problem through the same lens. They are not interchangeable, nor should they be.
Yet they all live and work within the same frame, and that frame has a rather important purpose.
The submarine and its frame protect the crew in an environment in which they could not survive on their own. The crew, in turn, has a shared responsibility to protect the submarine.
The relationship works in both directions. The frame protects the crew, while the crew protects the frame. Neither works particularly well without the other.
Earning Your Dolphins
One of the traditions that binds a submarine crew together is submarine warfare qualification, the process that ultimately allows a sailor or officer to wear the submarine warfare insignia commonly known as “dolphins.” Qualification extends far beyond knowing your individual job. Submariners must develop a broader understanding of the ship, its systems, casualty procedures, damage control, watchstanding, and the responsibilities involved in keeping the submarine operating and fighting.
There is a reason for that breadth of knowledge. The people evaluating a young sailor or a young officer’s qualification for their warfare specialty need to be confident that they could be the one who saves the ship and, as a result, saves the lives of the crew in the event of an emergency or during war.

That does not mean the cook becomes a nuclear operator, the yeoman becomes a sonar technician, or everyone aboard suddenly possesses the knowledge and authority of the commanding officer. Qualification does not eliminate specialization. It connects specialization to shared responsibility.
The submarine needs specialists, but it needs something more than a collection of specialists. It needs a crew.
The Fiduciary Table Is Not So Different
Think about the people sitting around a fiduciary committee table. One person may come from Human Resources, another from Finance, and another may have a legal or operational background. Around that committee may be an investment advisor, ERISA counsel, recordkeeper, investment managers, auditors, consultants, and other specialists.
Those individuals bring different expertise, experiences, and points of view. That can be a strength.
Thoughtful fiduciary governance does not require everyone around the table to have the same expertise. It also does not require everyone around the table to look at issues through the same lens. It requires enough shared understanding that different expertise and different points of view can contribute to a shared fiduciary purpose.
The objective is not to make everyone think alike. The objective is to provide a framework strong enough that different people can exercise judgment within it while remaining connected to that shared fiduciary purpose.
The First Seven Principles Help Build the Frame
This eighth principle is, in many ways, the culmination of the seven that came before it. Each of the previous Signature Principles helps construct part of the fiduciary frame.
Consider the building blocks we have explored:
- Define the problem before evaluating the solution.
- Recognize that prudence and loyalty, process and purpose, must work together.
- Allow examples to inform judgment rather than define it.
- Use checklists to organize judgment rather than replace it.
- Create flexibility within well defined boundaries.
- Document not simply what fiduciaries did, but why they did it.
- Evaluate innovation thoughtfully rather than reflexively embracing or avoiding it.
None of these principles provides a formula for the correct fiduciary answer. Together, however, they provide building blocks for a framework within which thoughtful fiduciary judgment can occur.
If you are new to this series, or if you have not had an opportunity to review the earlier installments, the first seven Signature Principles provide a useful foundation for thinking about the framework we are discussing here. Each principle adds something to the frame, but none eliminates the need for judgment.
When the Formula Runs Out
For many routine fiduciary responsibilities, established processes work extraordinarily well. Policies, procedures, checklists, monitoring criteria, meeting calendars, and established governance practices can bring discipline and consistency to fiduciary oversight.
Eventually, however, something will not fit neatly within the established process. It might be a new investment structure, a new technology, an unusual participant need, a service provider issue, a regulatory change, a market event, or simply a circumstance nobody anticipated when the checklist was written.
That is when the difference between a formula and a framework becomes especially important.
A formula tells us what to do when the facts fit the formula. A framework helps us decide what to do when they do not.
As we discussed earlier in this series, checklists can organize judgment, but they cannot replace it. When the checklist ends, the framework remains.
Governance, Stewardship, and Leadership
There are different ways to construct a fiduciary framework. One example comes from the Behavioral Governance Institute, which defines Behavioral Governance as the study of the interrelationships between leadership, stewardship, and governance. It is a professional standard designed to complement industry regulations by considering not only the requirements that govern a decision, but also the human behaviors and responsibilities that influence how those decisions are made.

Within that framework, the Behavioral Governance Institute defines the three concepts as follows:
- Leadership: The capacity to inspire and engage others.
- Stewardship: The passion and discipline to protect the long-term interests of those being served.
- Governance: The ability to manage the details of a prudent decision-making process.
There is an important connection between these three concepts and the framework we have been discussing throughout this series. Governance brings discipline to the decision-making process. Stewardship keeps the long-term interests of those being served at the center of that process. Leadership helps engage and inspire the people responsible for carrying it out. Together, they illustrate why fiduciary excellence involves more than mechanically satisfying a collection of requirements.
This does not mean that every committee, advisor, or service provider needs to adopt the Behavioral Governance Institute’s framework. In fact, that would run counter to the larger point of this Signature Principle. Different organizations may construct their frameworks differently based upon their responsibilities, philosophies, resources, and the people they serve. The important question is whether you have a framework, whether you understand it, whether you can articulate it, and whether it helps guide thoughtful judgment when the answer is not obvious.
A framework does not tell everyone what to think. It helps people understand how to think about their responsibilities and the purpose they are trying to serve.
A Submarine Is Not a Battleship
Return for a moment to our Navy analogy. The frame of a submarine is significantly different from the frame of a battleship. It has to be because they are designed to operate in different environments and under different conditions. Yet both ultimately support a common purpose, maritime warfare and maritime defense.
Fiduciary frameworks can differ in much the same way. For example:
- An advisor may build its practice primarily around investment due diligence and fiduciary process.
- Another advisor may place one-on-one participant education at the center of its work.
- Another may approach retirement benefits through a broader framework of total financial wellbeing.
- A committee may view its retirement plan as part of an integrated benefits strategy.
- Another committee may take a more paternal approach to helping employees prepare successfully for retirement.
Different circumstances, resources, philosophies, participant populations, and responsibilities can produce different frameworks. The question is not whether every frame looks the same. The better questions are whether you know what your framework is, whether you can articulate it, whether the people working alongside you understand it, and whether it helps you exercise judgment when the answer is not obvious.
Most importantly, does your framework keep your shared fiduciary purpose and the participants you serve at the center?
The Frame Protects the Crew, and the Crew Protects the Frame
A submarine’s frame makes it possible for people to operate in an environment in which they otherwise could not survive. But steel alone cannot save a submarine. The people inside must understand the ship, maintain it, monitor it, recognize when something is wrong, respond when a casualty occurs, exercise judgment, and, when circumstances require it, fight to save it.
The same relationship exists in fiduciary governance. An Investment Policy Statement, committee charter, checklist, or monitoring report does not exercise judgment. People exercise judgment. Yet those structures matter enormously because they create an environment within which people can exercise judgment responsibly.
That is why fiduciary excellence requires both a strong frame and people capable of operating within it. The framework supports the fiduciaries. The fiduciaries, through their governance, stewardship, and leadership, preserve and strengthen the framework.
Suggested Action Items
For Fiduciary Committee Members
At an upcoming committee meeting, consider setting the normal agenda aside for a few minutes and asking a deceptively simple question:
“What is our fiduciary framework?”
Do not begin by opening the Investment Policy Statement or committee charter. Let the members answer. What principles guide your decisions? What are you ultimately trying to accomplish for participants? How do you make decisions when circumstances are not contemplated by an existing policy or checklist? What responsibilities belong to the committee, and where does the committee rely on the expertise of others?
As one example, at 90 North Consulting we consistently use the phrase “Be More Than a Fiduciary.” Our framework begins with meeting the legal requirements imposed by ERISA, the Internal Revenue Code, and other applicable law. Those obligations are the foundation, not the finish line. From there, we ask fiduciaries to go further, to do more, to be stewards, and to seek to achieve more on behalf of the participants they serve.
That is one part of the 90 North framework.
What would your equivalent answer be?
For ERISA Advisors
Ask the same question of your own practice: “What framework guides the way we advise fiduciary clients?”
Perhaps your framework emphasizes investment due diligence and fiduciary process. Perhaps it emphasizes participant education, financial well being, plan outcomes, or some combination of those concepts. Whatever the answer, consider whether your clients understand that framework and whether it strengthens their framework rather than substituting your process for their judgment.
For Service Providers
Ask what role your organization believes it plays within the fiduciary ecosystem. Consider the expertise and perspective you bring, what excellent service to plan fiduciaries and participants looks like, and how your framework complements the frameworks of the committees and advisors you serve.
A service provider does not necessarily need to share every aspect of a client’s framework, just as every member of a submarine crew does not share the same specialty. The important question is whether those different roles and perspectives can operate together in support of a shared fiduciary purpose.
Final Thoughts
A submarine does not become effective simply because talented specialists have been assigned to it. Those specialists must become a crew. They retain their individual expertise, responsibilities, personalities, experiences, and points of view, but they operate within a common frame. They develop shared understanding, accept shared responsibilities, and ultimately serve a common mission.
Fiduciary committees and the professionals who surround them are also more than collections of specialists. The objective is not uniformity of thought. It is different expertise and different points of view operating within a strong framework toward a shared fiduciary purpose.
The first seven Signature Principles help build that frame. The eighth reminds us why the frame matters.
Fiduciary excellence is a framework, not a formula.
Continuing the Conversation
This concludes our exploration of the eight individual Signature Principles of Thoughtful Fiduciary Leadership, but it does not quite conclude the series. Next week, we will step back from the individual principles and consider what these eight lessons, taken together, can teach us about thoughtful fiduciary leadership and what it means to Be More Than a Fiduciary.
We hope this newsletter inspires you to think beyond the basics of fiduciary responsibility and embrace a more holistic, impactful approach to leadership, stewardship, and governance. Please feel free to share this with your network, and don’t hesitate to reach out for further discussion or resources.
Explore the full discussion of the Signature Principle Eight in our LinkedIn article.





