An ERISA Carol: From Humbug to Stewardship

A seasonal reflection for fiduciaries ready to trade legal checklists for leadership and purpose

Each December, my wife and I make time for a tradition: watching A Christmas Carol.  But not just any version. We always watch the FX adaptation starring Guy Pearce. It’s dark, intense, and not for young children (it’s rated TV-MA), but it’s easily the most emotionally deep and honest version of the story I’ve seen.

What sets this adaptation apart isn’t just its cinematic weight.  What sets it apart is it’s how deeply it explores why Scrooge became who he is. What formed him? What hardened him? What would it take to change him? His emotional journey is rooted in trauma, abuse, fear, and eventual redemption, mirrors the experience many fiduciaries may have when navigating the heavy world of ERISA responsibility.

This newsletter is a seasonal reflection on what it means to evolve, not just from noncompliance to compliance, but from compliance to true stewardship. In that spirit, I offer you “An ERISA Carol“.

The celebrity in the image is Andy Serkis, who played the character of the Ghost of Christmas Present in the 2019 BBC/FX mini-series A Christmas Carol.

The Humbug of Fiduciary Fatigue

The word fiduciary alone can suck the life out of a committee room. It’s a term that should inspire leadership and trust, but for many plan sponsors, it only brings pressure, legal risk, and fear of personal liability.

In the FX adaptation, we get a revealing glimpse into young Scrooge’s life. Before Ebeneezer is visited via the ghost of Christmas past, he is visited by the ghost of his father.  His father’s visit is not to warn or encourage, not to celebrate, but to impose control. His message is clear: the world is cruel, and the only way to survive is through discipline and detachment. Affection is weakness. Responsibility is punishment. Love is a liability.  Instead rule with an iron fist and with no compassion.

Many fiduciaries first hear about their role in the same cold terms: “You can be personally liable.” “One mistake could lead to litigation.” “Do only what’s necessary to stay out of trouble.” That tone may drive compliance, but it does little to cultivate leadership. The result? A generation of fiduciaries is more concerned with legal exposure than participant outcomes.


The Ghost of Fiduciary Past: Meeting the Minimum

In the early decades of ERISA oversight, fiduciary governance was primarily procedural. Investment policy? Check. Minutes? Filed. Documentation? Complete. Risk was contained by staying in the lines.  Containing risk is appropriate and preferred, but few asked if those lines actually led anywhere meaningful.

Joe Alwyn as Bob Cratchit in the 2019 BBCFX miniseries adaptation of A Christmas Carol

Scrooge, in his early life, did what he was taught: control, calculate, isolate. He meets his obligations but offers nothing more. Bob Cratchit, by contrast, models stewardship. He leads with compassion. He protects what matters. He doesn’t carry a formal title, but he lives out the duty of care that every fiduciary should strive for.

He is, in many ways, a much better and model fiduciary compared to the man who signs his paycheck.

The Ghost of Fiduciary Present: The Ice is Getting Thinner

Today, fiduciaries operate in a more demanding world. Lawsuits, fee pressure, regulatory changes, and yet many committees remain stuck in the past. Meetings become routine. Reviews become checkbox exercises. Governance begins to drift.

That’s what makes one particular scene in the FX adaptation so memorable. Scrooge, now awakened to what’s at stake, is shown a vision of Tiny Tim’s death not because of cruelty, but because of indifference, and momentary neglect. But this time, Scrooge doesn’t wait.

Once awakened from his dream, and on Christmas morning, before Tim ever leaves his home, Scrooge walks to the frozen pond and begins scattering rocks across the ice. He knows the ice is thin. He knows it’s dangerous. And for the first time, he acts not out of fear or obligation, but because he now understands the value of the life he’s protecting.  A life where he can for once make a positive difference.

Thin ice is what many fiduciaries are walking across when they cling to “just enough.” When investment menus grow stale. When participant behavior is misunderstood. When the plan operates in default mode. No immediate disaster, but the risk is real.

Governance is not about skating the edge. It’s about scattering the rocks and setting a sound direction before harm occurs.

The Ghost of Fiduciary Future: What Story Will You Write?

The future isn’t written in stone, but it is shaped by every decision fiduciaries make today. Inaction has consequences. But so does leadership. When committees step into their role with confidence, clarity, and purpose, participant outcomes improve.

That’s not a theory. That’s a reality we see every day in our work at 90 North.

But confidence requires preparation. And one of the most consistent truths across the retirement plan space is that fiduciaries often step into their role with very little training. They are handed a seat at the table and expected to understand the complexities of ERISA law, investment oversight, plan design, and vendor accountability without meaningful guidance.

It doesn’t have to be that way.

At 90 North, we’ve developed a practical, on-demand training series through 90 North University, designed specifically for plan fiduciaries.  Plan fiduciaries and all other industry professionals as well.  It’s not legalese. It’s not abstract. It’s training that helps committees think clearly, govern effectively, and lead confidently.

You can explore it at 90northllc.com/90-north-university. It’s one of the ways we’re helping plan sponsors move from obligation to stewardship.

Redemption: Becoming More Than a Fiduciary

On Christmas morning, Scrooge doesn’t go looking for a checklist. He looks for people. He listens. He acts. He becomes something new.  Not because he has to, but because he wants to.

This image is a still from the 2019 BBC/FX miniseries A Christmas Carol. 


The characters shown are Ebenezer Scrooge, played by Guy Pearce, and the Ghost of Christmas Present, played by Charlotte Riley.

That’s the invitation every fiduciary committee has in front of them. You are not just administrators of compliance. You are stewards of people’s futures. You are protecting lives, not just following rules. Being a fiduciary is the role. Becoming a steward is the transformation.

Three Steps Toward Stewardship

If you’re ready to take the next step, here’s where to start:

Revisit the purpose behind your role. What are you protecting, and who are you serving?

Evaluate your training. Are you and your committee equipped for the work you’ve been asked to do?

Consider exploring 90 North University. It’s a simple, accessible way to build confidence and clarity around what it means to serve as a fiduciary.

And maybe not a step towards ERISA stewardship, but I do hope you will join me this season in watching FX’s A Christmas Carol.

A New Day for Fiduciaries

The most powerful moment in A Christmas Carol isn’t about regret, it’s about what comes next. It’s Scrooge, scattering stones across the pond. Quiet. Intentional. Protective.

That’s stewardship.

And this season, that’s the transformation worth embracing.

Wishing you rest, clarity, and renewed purpose as the year draws to a close. We hope this newsletter inspires you to think beyond the basics of fiduciary responsibility and embrace a more holistic, impactful approach to leadership, stewardship, and governance. Please feel free to share this with your network, and don’t hesitate to reach out for further discussion or resources.

Read more in our LinkedIn article:

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/erisa-carol-from-humbug-stewardship-eric-vqcmc

Eric Dyson Executive Director 90 North Consulting

Executive Director, 90 North Consulting

edyson@90northllc.com

940-248-4800

The information and content of this newsletter is general in nature and is provided solely for educational and informational purposes. It is believed to be accurate and reliable as of the posting date but may be subject to change

It is not intended to provide a specific recommendation for any type of product or service discussed or to provide any warranties, investment advice, financial advice, tax, plan design or legal advice (unless otherwise specifically indicated). Please consult your own independent advisor or legal counsel as to any investment, tax, or legal statements made.

The specific facts and circumstances of all qualified plans can vary and the information contained in this newsletter may or may not apply to your individual circumstances or to your plan or client plan-specific circumstances.

Check out our latest podcast episodes

1x

Stay Informed: Explore Our Latest Newsletter Articles

Introducing Polaris

Introducing POLARIS

Beyond the Investment Policy Statement: From Fiduciary Policy to Fiduciary Practice Why Meaningful Benchmark Selection Deserves a More Deliberate Fiduciary Process From Confusion to Compliance

Read More >>